Hello everyone- with this storyline entering the EN dub (a full review will follow once all its episodes are online); I thought it would be aa good idea to address this arc. Though it did do a lot to improve on the issues I had with the previous storylines; there are other areas that could still use improvement. Here are my thoughts on Pokémon Horizons’ Terastal Debut; and why it’s the most conflicted I’ve ever felt about this anime so far.
Let’s start with what works and what’s improved, as usual. The animation is still the strongest aspect; and though others have denied this, the “Tera Leak” suggests that a pivot did happen from their plans to an extent.
I actually was in favor of using this storyline as a soft reset that not only brought in more aspects from the games; but it also seemed designed to take a sledgehammer to each issue I had with the new leads. Dot viewing social interaction as a waste of time? Iono being paired for one of her challenges had no choice but to crack that barrier open like an egg. Roy acting impulsive and rushing headfirst into scenarios without a plan? Ryme is able to easily read this line of attack and causes him to reevaluate why he’s on his adventure. Liko being hesitant to engage with others, especially in battle? Both mentors and enemies are not exercising restraint with her, which becomes a catalyst for the rest of the story thus far. I also appreciate the inclusion of Nemona; and Penny.
That’s not to say that I still don’t have issues with the story. Call me crazy, but I’m not among those who thinks HZ “fixed” the issues, real or perceived with the previous seasons (JN in particular). I’m among those who maintain they were exacerbated; or at least, manifested in different ways. The short reason is this- a child viewer likely won't care for boring dealings at Friede’s former workplace; and a viewer my age likely won’t be amused by scenes involving a Varoom absconding with a Nidorina costume. The longer reason starts with this- even kids can tell when a story isn’t like its source material; and there are older viewers like me who are not above overlooking Horizons’ flaws.
I mean, it’s odd that this anime still insists on using fan-favorite aspects from the games in such a perfunctory way (Arven not having any lines, the box legendaries of SV being conspicuous by their absence so far) and changing others in ways that didn’t need to be (Grusha being among the most divisive). I will touch on this further in a full review as well as when Rayquaza Rising concludes; but in lots of ways, this anime is doing a bigger disservice to Generation IX than its predecessor did to Generation VIII. I can’t say I’m entirely surprised about plans to wrap it up and go back to basics for the next anime. I will address that idea at a later date in the year; but for now, I think it’s unlikely that HZ will get a movie and more likely that the anime as a whole will get a reboot (like James Gunn is doing with Superman and the DCU).
You might also be wondering why I’m not mentioning ratings in regards to this storyline. It turns out that they actually stopped reporting the numbers nearly a year ago. I know there’s the whole transition to digital streaming; but the HZ anime hasn’t cracked the top 10 list on Netflix in ages. There’s only so much blame to affix to their staggered release schedule, as I did theorize (correctly) that people would direct their attention elsewhere if things continued this way. Other reimagined stories on Netflix alone that have gotten the audience HZ was targeting include originals such as Sonic Prime and Jurassic World: Chaos Theory as well as getting recent hits such as Tales of the TMNT and Star Trek Prodigy.
One last thing to mention is this- despite the creative license taken; this storyline is honestly the adaptation of Pokémon Scarlet and Violet that HZ should have been from the start. That has honestly been the bigger adjustment than the changes in “anchor” characters and story structure. The success of Sonic the Hedgehog 3 has proven that giving people what they want does have its advantages.
Overall, the “Terastal Debut” storyline demonstrates my overall feelings towards Pokémon Horizons- there are elements that really work; but many others that keep it from reaching its full potential. I am not certain whether the next anime will bring back “you know who” or just adapt the games directly (either of which I would support); but I personally don’t see the HZ model being duplicated for future iterations come Generation X. That is all for now, and I’m back to my 33rd birthday week.